Submission Details

Full Name:
Royce WILES
Business/Organisation (if applicable):
Matamata Historical Society Incorporated
Date Submitted
2024-04-19 21:09:22

Walking and cycling improvements

What do you think we should do?

Alternative option: Continue to steadily improve walking and cycling connections, but over a longer time frame?

Do you have any comments on this?

Tower Road Pedestrian: rather than cut this completely, we would prefer to complete this project in 2024/25 because of the multitude of benefits of this infrastructure. The Tower Road walkway aligns with Hauraki Rail Trail infrastructure, and provides a low-cost walking or cycling route for Matamata residents who wish a 30-45 minute walk out of town, terminating at Firth Tower Museum (with important public toilet available) this is an ideal turn around for town-based walkers or cyclists. There is no other safe semi-rural walk in the town and a survey of who uses the path shows that young mothers with prams, parents with children, more senior cyclists etc. all benefit. There is a wide range of users for this community asset. With the Longlands complex at the other end of Burwood Road this is a significant asset for residents to enjoy—without direct cost.


Town Centre infrastructure

What do you think we should do?

Proposed option: Prioritise maintenance and renewals and Pride of Place?

Do you have any comments on this?

Town Centre Improvements (Matamata): we do not think these projects are a priority, in particular because some of the consultancy work for Pride of Place (in our view) failed to engage with historical concerns—for example no staff were available to come meet Matamata Historical Society members / volunteers when we approached them, and instead we were asked to have a Zoom consultation or failing that on paper when our demographic is older residents who prefer a face-to-face consultation or at least a meeting. Firth Tower Museum is based outside the urban area and so internet speeds do not favour Zoom meetings. For reasons such as this we think longer consultation, a more measured approach and prioritising maintenance a better option until the planning can be more soundly based; e.g. flaws in the Hetana Street proposals which did not even recognise that the name of the Street is the Māori form of Prime Minister Seddon’s name, the report thought it could have been ‘a local settler family’. The lack of engagement with local history compromises the consultancy work done and less effort seems to have been spent on the Pride of Place teams ‘coming up-to-speed’ about local history in Matamata at least. A walk through down-town Matamata shows the pavements grubby and litter bins not clean—perhaps the fundamentals can be the focus until the economy settles somewhat.


Additional playgrounds

What do you think we should do?

Proposed option: Limit playground improvements to the planned new playgrounds for Te Aroha and Matamata?

Do you have any comments on this?

Additional playgrounds: we do not have views on these topics, although as above, the lack of historical background on the uses of the Matamata Domain during World War II and the prime importance of the oak trees in the Matamata playground commemorating the first Matamata soldiers killed-in-action are important to us.


Stage for the Matamata-Piako Civic and Memorial Centre

What do you think we should do?

Proposed option: Remove this project from our work programme?

Do you have any comments on this?

Matamata Civic Centre stage: we were delighted that the war memorial shrine was preserved in the new building, albeit with a raised floor and reduced overhead space—this was a prime artistic installation commemorating events which left a deep mark on the Matamata district in terms of deaths overseas (no bodies were returned so this was the only place for expressions of grief and remembrance). A stage is not a priority for our work and we do not think removing it from the programme will impact our organisation.


The services we provide

What do you think we should do?

Proposed option: Continue to provide all the current services, to mostly the same standard?

Any other comments on this?

Firth Tower Museum as a community asset: the proposal to “review operating hours and/or the future direction of our facilities – such as pools, libraires, Council offices, Firth Tower, and Te Aroha i-SITE” can certainly impact the functioning of the Firth Tower Museum which is run as a collaboration between MPDC and MHS. For the past 40 years (since 1978) the Matamata Historical Society has been working at the Firth Tower Museum site (at first with the Matamata Borough Council and then MPDC) to build and maintain a unique outdoor and indoor museum precinct on one of the very few historical reserves within MPDC boundaries. The purpose of the museum is to provide a cultural hub which is also a central point for cumulation of local history information and resources. There are multiple layers of use for the site which may not be clear to outsiders, an attempt will be made to list groups of users of the museum who benefit from its current opening hours and the fruitful working relationship between MPDC and MHS personnel. So, who is visiting Firth Tower Museum and why (1) locals from the district interested in the history of the area, they may or may not be descendants of earlier generations of settlers; they may also be new residents who have down-sized to retirement locations in town (e.g. Longlands, Matamata Country Club, etc.); (2) visitors from other areas of New Zealand passing through but who have an interest in local history (or who need a place for the kid to stretch their legs); (3) international tourists looking for a local activity to add to the list of Hobbiton and the Wairere Falls (in particular that awkward half day either before or after a Hobbiton tour); (4) local individuals planning weddings—the Firth Tower Museum church (1914) is one of the cheaper and more accessible (i.e., cheap) venues for wedding ceremonies and also the only ‘vintage’ such venue in town; (5) parents or grand-parents who need a safe, interesting outdoor environment to take children for a few hours (if only to get them away from screens or Minecraft); (6) local iwi visiting the Tamihana stone cairn; (7) cyclists on the Hauraki Rail Trail passing by who are interested to find out what the landmark Tower is or was for (some of course only stop for a breather); (8) collectors looking to see if we have examples of local bottle ware, ceramics; (9) individuals with properties (urban or rural) looking for old photos of their home or office—a number of business in town have historic photos reproduced and on show on their walls (very much ‘pride of place’); (10) family tree researchers looking for local resident information, farm maps, cemetery records etc. (11) people wanting to ‘donate’ antique or vintage items of local historical interest (especially if their children do not want them); (12) motor rally clubs looking for a spacious place to meet, park up to display their cars, have a picnic etc.; (13) retirement homes from far and near needing a quiet, traffic-free, walkable place to bring seniors for a few hours (some with walking frames and others with cognitive decline issues); (14) campers needing a moderately priced park spot for the night—in particular international tourists heading back to Auckland airport the next day who do not want to be too far from Auckland, but also not too close); (15) local individuals focused on art (Art society) (16) local community groups using our Heritage room for meetings (Writers' group, Spinners and Weavers) (17) Place to begin a fun run (Tower Fun Run) (18) Families from different regions choosing to meet in the middle and coming to Firth Tower Museum for a combined picnic (coming from Taupo, Auckland, Tauranga etc.). There are more categories (e.g., garden clubs) but the idea is clear I think—Firth Tower Museum as it currently operates for the public is a site of exceptionally varied use and a major asset for both individuals, businesses, schools, retirement homes and others in the area. It is difficult to find a parallel with such a local history, local icon, park-like grounds facility: perhaps those familiar with Auckland would regard the War Memorial Museum in the Auckland Domain as such a location. Firth Tower Museum is Matamata’s scaled down version. MPDC staff keep the museum open in a way volunteers cannot, they also ensure site safety, maintain health and safety compliance and other more administrative functions. The Matamata Historical Society regards the current opening hours of the facility as the minimum ones (i.e., six hours a day x five days a week = 30 hours) and have in the past tried to get these expanded to seven days a week and public holidays included—we realise now may not be the time to achieve that target. However, maintenance of what we have now is our preferred position.


Te Aroha Library

What do you think we should do?

Proposed option: Investigate and deliver a suitable building to continue providing library services in Te Aroha?

Any other comments on Te Aroha Library:

Te Aroha Library: we regard the historical ambience developed in Te Aroha by this building, by the i-SITE building, by the Domain museum etc. major achievements in terms of preserving and enhancing the built environment and heritage of the town. Understanding the difficulties of earthquake risk management, we think the current building a superb example of re-purposing of public buildings in an aesthetic and attractive way (filled with details like the glass in the doors, the brass plates etc.). In no way do we think shutting down the Te Aroha library a good thing. If anything, the economic uncertainties within New Zealand and abroad means we need to protect those elements of our urban infrastructure which are of great public benefit—in particular to those who are not ‘well off’. Libraries (like street lighting) offer significant benefits to those less privileged, those older and unable to travel outside the town easily and those who need to enrich children’s lives with books they would otherwise have to try to purchase.

Back to submission listing